Thursday, March 29, 2012

On Teenage Heartbreak

I haven’t posted anything for a while because I figured there were only so many stages of grief that people would be willing to read about before overload set in. This past week, however, my concern has shifted from my own grief to that of my 18-year-old son, who has just gone through one of the unfortunate rites of passage of adolescence: rejection by a girl.

Jeremy is a sweet, good-natured, extraordinarily talented boy who also happens to be shy and self-conscious. He will, I know, develop into a poised, confident adult by the time many of his more self-assured classmates have begun to fizzle and burn after crashing against life’s more bitter truths. I also know from experience that that may take a long, long time, and I don’t envy him the years in between, because they are likely to be lonely and frustrating.

What I do remember—and what I’m going to keep trying to explain to Jeremy—is that at his age, if you’re shy, artistic and unathletic, there are going to be basically three types of girls. There are the popular girls who never notice that you exist. There are the friendly girls who make you so tongue-tied you’re lucky if you can begin a coherent sentence in their presence, let alone finish it. And then there are the really mean girls, and given that the likelihood of your ever having a conversation with either of the first two types is nil, these are the ones you are likely to encounter first.

Jeremy just met one of them. He has, of course, been having a horrible senior year. Sure, he got into Baylor and was courted by several other colleges, sang at NATS (don’t ask), has been a part of two outstanding choirs and nearly made All-State. His mother also died two days before Christmas, and that tends to cast a pall over everything else. (If you didn’t know this, a pall is something they place over the casket at a funeral in commemoration of the departed’s baptism. It’s an apt metaphor.)

So I was as pleased as punch when Jeremy got home from work the week before last and told me and Jennifer that a girl he worked with had asked him to the prom at her private school. See, I knew there was no way Jeremy would ever get up the nerve to ask any of those friendly girls to go anywhere. We seem to run into them everywhere we go, and they usually give Jeremy a big smile and greet him warmly. As I well remember, the natural, pre-programmed reaction of a shy, nerdy guy (let’s just use the abbreviation SNG) to such overtures is profound embarrassment accompanied by a desperate desire to be anywhere else in the world as long as it can get you out of having to come up with something to say in response. Yeah, it is that bad.

But my SNG had been asked to the prom, and had said yes. Since she went to a private school, she had to ask him, not vice-versa. But Jeremy now told me, with no little satisfaction, that she had been acting like she liked him for some time, and that he had been thinking about inviting her to the prom at Midway, his own high school. Since I was once an 18-year-old SNG, I know perfectly well that all he would have ever done was think about it. The chances of him actually asking were nil. But she had asked him.

Then he came home from school a few days ago and showed me a text message he had received from his prom date, indicating that she was suddenly having second thoughts. He didn’t know anybody at her school, and it might be awkward. They were polar opposites: she outgoing, he painfully shy. I pretty much told him to text her back that all of that didn’t matter; he wanted to go to the prom with her. To my great parental pride and satisfaction, he managed to get off several such messages in a row, showing entirely proper interest in their “relationship” and indicating that he wanted to continue it, despite her newfound doubts. My boy was doing brilliantly.

And every one of his messages was rebuffed with more “idk’s” and “Well, ums…” and so forth. So I did what any good father would do under the circumstances. I wrote an email to her father, telling him that his daughter was taking unfair advantage of a wonderful, generous and caring boy who had just lost his mother, and that her repeated rebuffs had reduced him to tears such as I hadn’t seen since the week his mother died. Her father wrote back and assured me that he had had a significant talk with his daughter, who tended to say things she really didn’t mean, and that he could assure me that she and Jeremy would be going to the prom together. That message came in to my cell phone at about 11:00 at night, and I literally wept with relief and gratitude.

Then yesterday she dealt the coup de grace. Once again by text message, she bluntly informed him that she had gotten back together with her boyfriend and that she and Jeremy were history. This time he managed to stammer back a few incoherent responses, which was more than I would have been able to manage at his age, and she repeatedly and coldly snubbed him.

So here I am having watched the inevitable mean girl twist the knife in my poor boy’s heart, wondering desperately why he still can’t untie his tongue sufficiently to ask one of the nice ones to the prom with him. Unfortunately, I know the answer. After this experience, his tongue is now so firmly and emphatically tied that it will probably be a couple of years before he looks seriously at a girl again. I hope that’s not the case, but yeah, it is that bad. I remember all too well.

Saturday, March 3, 2012

Limbo

There is a kind of loneliness that relates not to immediate circumstances but to habits of life. At 56, I have learned to be present to myself and to enjoy my own company. I would not hesitate to eat at a restaurant or even take a vacation by myself; in fact, there is something marvelously seductive about the latter prospect. Right now I am savoring a Saturday evening at home while both kids are at work. I don’t mind being alone.

I felt great sadness, though, when I read a recent article in the New York Times: yet another in a seemingly endless series of examinations of my well-known cohort, the baby boomers. It seems that a lot of us are deciding to enter into old age more or less permanently single. The most frequent reason is divorce, and the prospect of a solitary old age apparently appeals more to many of us than that of one spent in an unhappy marriage, or in a marriage of any kind.

As I read this, I couldn’t help but feel the painful irony of my own situation. I had a wonderful marriage, and I had assumed (perhaps against reasonable expectation) that Barbara and I would continue together for a few more decades. Among the texts read at our wedding was one from chapter 8 of the Apocryphal book of Tobit. As Tobias prepares to take the repeatedly widowed Sarah as his wife, he prays “that I may find mercy and may grow old together with her.” We chose this text for an obvious reason: Barbara had been widowed once, and we were asking, as Tobias was, that she not be widowed again. In that sense, the prayer was fulfilled. I notice now that the entire text, which begins by calling for God’s name to be blessed throughout creation and ends with the couple saying “Amen” together, resonates with the familiar Hebrew prayer known as the Mourner’s Kaddish, and I prayerfully rejoice that I remained with Barbara until her death did us part.

But I also cherished the idea of growing old together with her. Nothing could seem like a more appropriate fulfillment of a life spent in mutual devotion. The bitterness of old age would be softened by the timely maturing of our long-held love. I have always wept at Richard Strauss’s song Im Abendrot, in which the octogenarian composer sets Eichendorff’s poem about an elderly couple facing the evening of life together. (O weiter, stiller Friede! So tief im Abendrot. Wie sind wir wandermüde—Ist dies etwa der Tod?) I wrote in my last post of the sense of purpose I receive from knowing that I helped Barbara to fulfill her dream of having a family and children. That doesn’t keep me from aching at the knowledge that I will miss that final chapter.

As Barbara and I were forced to work overtime to continue to share our most painful emotions, we became experts at intimacy. We had laid the groundwork for that expertise during our years as presenters for Lutheran Marriage Encounter, when we led weekend retreats to help married couples develop their communication skills. For us, though, it came to fruition during the years after Barbara’s deafness made it impossible for us to continue in that role. Without it, I doubt if we would have been prepared for the challenge of completely redefining the terms of our relationship. As it was, we continued to prioritize our marriage, even as it meant shunning more and more outside social contacts that her deafness had rendered increasingly futile.

Without her, I am lamenting the absence of something that I know many couples never achieve. I am used to sharing deeply, and I have no-one to share with. This is a permanent problem, just as it would be if my hands were crippled by arthritis and I could no longer play the piano. For a non-musician, the arthritis would be an inconvenience. For me, it would be a kind of death.

I have already been told, by quite a few people in various direct or indirect ways, that I am still young, that I am still attractive, that I will no doubt find love again. Since I have no desire to face old age alone, I will acknowledge that they may be right, although at present I can’t even imagine what that would be like. The hole in my life feels unfillable, the non-circumstantial loneliness like a permanent but unmeetable need. When that no longer seems true, I suppose I will have reached what grief counselors like to call my “new normal.” For now, any kind of normal still seems a long way off.

Thursday, February 23, 2012

Purpose

A 23-year-old woman, fresh from college and just beginning her career as a nurse, receives a sudden and devastating diagnosis: She has an astrocytoma—a malignant brain tumor—growing in her cerebellum. This is a really bad tumor to have, since astrocytes are the star-shaped glial cells that hold the brain together. When they start growing out of control, the resulting mess is almost impossible to remove, so even with successful surgery the prognosis is for a near certain, inoperable return. In order to put this off for as long as possible, she receives a lifetime dose of radiation.

Fast-forward six years. The young woman has, inexplicably, survived. She has fallen in love and gotten married. She has become pregnant. Then, once again inexplicably, her life is torn apart. Her husband is killed in a helicopter crash. A few weeks later, she miscarries, losing the life within her own body that provides a link with her former marriage and hopes. At 29, she is twice bereaved, and she is still a cancer survivor.

What are the chances that a woman in this position will live to have a family and children—her lifelong dream—and see those children grow to the cusp of adulthood?

I am speaking, of course, of my late wife Barbara. When I met her at age 32, she was settled in the condo she had bought with her own late husband, going to work and, in her own words, “just living.” It was hard for her to understand why she was still there, let alone what kind of prospects the future might hold.

I married Barbara in January of 1989. At the time, I probably didn’t look like much of a prospect either. I had no job, my trail of temporary positions after graduate school having dried up. I was overqualified for almost every other type of career, as I had found out through months of dogged, utterly unsuccessful searching. I am glad to say that Barbara believed in me, and that provided the shot in the arm I needed. It would be another five and a half years before I received a tenure-track college teaching job. Her faith in me was severely tested, as was mine.

By the time I got that job, we had two children, who were respectively two and a half years and five months old. These were the only children to bless our 23 years of marriage. You might assume that was because we used birth control. You would be wrong. We needed medical intervention in order to make it possible for us to conceive, not vice versa. What’s more, Barbara’s miscarriage turned out to have been due to a bifurcated uterus, which required surgery to repair. The odds were not in our favor, but we persisted, and our persistence was rewarded.

There were those who were cruel enough to suggest that by seeking medical help for our infertility, we were going against the will of God, who clearly did not intend for us to have children. It seems that some religious people feel justified in using their faith as an excuse to be as mean as possible to others whose circumstances they can’t begin to understand. I hope my reason for writing this now is clear.

Many have praised my courage and honesty in the two months since Barbara’s death. Truth be told, I have been struggling. There are days when it all seems too much, and that feeling still sneaks up and ambushes me at unexpected times, when my defenses are down. I’ve lived long enough to know that I have to ride with those feelings and not fight against them. Fortunately I have the kids, and they have been the world to me.

I have something else, too: a sense of purpose. By suffering through this loss, I have realized, I am still giving to Barbara. If we had not both hitched our wagons to an uncertain, unknowable future, I would not have been able to wait out the job market and fulfill my dreams for my career; she would not have had the family she yearned for. She suffered for her faith in me at the front end, through the doubts that many expressed to her about my prospects. Now I am suffering after her life has ended in the way I always knew was possible, even likely. By bearing it now, I am making it possible for my beloved to have realized her dream, just as she helped me realize mine. God bless you, Barbara—from all my heart.

Sunday, February 12, 2012

Valentine's Day

It’s the little things that hurt the most. As we gear up for our yearly celebration of the one holiday dedicated to romantic love, it has been relatively easy for me to ignore all the hearts and valentines on display. My wonderful daughter Jennifer has promised to go out to dinner with me on Tuesday night so I don’t have to feel the vast emptiness that would be left by eating at home.

Nevertheless, I just got back from an overnight trip to send Jeremy off on a college visit (his flight left from Austin, a 2-hour drive from here, at 8:04 this morning), and I’m feeling overwhelmed with painful reminders. This was the first time I had taken the kids on an overnight trip without Barbara. The first time I had checked into a hotel with them and without her. The first time I had driven past those familiar landmarks (“Got Dirty Birds?”) with only the kids in the car.

As we drove past BJ’s Restaurant and Brewhouse in Temple, I was curious about the menu, since a new one is going up in Waco. Jennifer pulled it up on her phone, and it was full of things Barbara would have loved — and I will now never have the chance to hear her gentle exhalation of delight upon finding them there herself. I will never witness her pleasure in trying out the Creole Tilapia or the Maui Glazed Pork Chop, or in sampling the specialty handcrafted beers.

Strangely enough, a stop at a gas station on the drive back cut to the quick. Walking into the convenience store to go to the bathroom after filling up the car reminded me that she was not lingering inside the ladies’ room, as she had so many times in the past. Our paths would simply not cross, and the question of whether the soda fountain sold Diet Dr. Pepper was now a matter of profound indifference to me. I didn’t even bother to look.

Jennifer and I returned in time for lunch, and the ache in my heart only grew as I realized there was nothing much to eat at home, and no place to go out that would not remind me of the many times I had gone there with Barbara: the menu choices we had made, the tables where we had sat together.

It is hard to escape from a pain that is so woven into the fabric of your everyday life that no pleasure, no diversion, no escape fails to remind you of the person who has shared it with you in the past. I sit now at the computer in my living room and look at the empty spot on the couch where she used to sit reading on afternoons like this. It is only the eighth Sunday that I have missed her presence there. It is only the eighth Sunday of my new existence, which twists and snakes through the future in unknown arcs to which I can’t yet provide the color that would make them things of beauty. Instead, the familiar shapes of daily life continue to grate at every turn, and they hurt far more than those pink hearts that now litter the horizon.

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

On the Sanctity of Marriage

Politicians and religious leaders love to talk about the sanctity of marriage. What I have to say here is deeply personal, but at the same time I think it reflects directly on our common understanding of what those words mean, or ought to mean. As events keep reminding us, sanctity does not belong to marriage as an institution. Rather, it is something that can occur through the institution of marriage, but only with great effort and often with considerable suffering. If people have a trivial view of marriage that is not open to that suffering, the institution can be awfully unforgiving.

To be sanctified is to be made whole, which also means being touched by something greater than yourself. Marriage is a wonderful conduit for sanctification because, while it is undertaken in love, it often breaks us. People talk about broken marriages, but the truth is, it is marriage that breaks us, not the other way around.

It happens when things don’t go as you’d planned; when your beloved turns out to be someone different than the idealized partner you had created in your own mind. For some, this is the greatest challenge they will face, and it probably causes more divorces than any other. Sanctification is what comes when you begin to realize that living with that real person is worth the effort. It means you have to grow out at the edges so that your edges can continue to mesh. It means there will be bumping and shoving as you get settled into your new shapes. As the hymn that was sung at Barbara’s funeral goes:

If you find someone to share your time
and you join your hearts as one,
I'll be there to make your verses rhyme
from dusk 'till rising sun.

Yes, Lord, but the verses don’t always go smoothly, and the night is often dark. So much the better. Marriage sanctifies because it forces us to confront things in another person—and hence, ultimately, in ourselves—with which we’re uncomfortable; of which we’re afraid. It is these very things that must be explored if we are to grow spiritually: to outpace our limitations and become a soul whose scope and reach is the world at large.

When Barbara and I met, we instantly and instinctively bonded because we had both had to overcome things that most people in their early 30s never dream of dealing with. The symmetry of our life experiences drew us together in a way that far transcended the obvious differences between us. From the very beginning we treasured each other, and when you have treasured someone in that way, it is worth being broken repeatedly in order to remain what you have become for that person: a kindred spirit; a familiar patch in a foreign world; flesh of my flesh and soul of my soul.

When Barbara became sick, both of us suffered equally. This happened again and again. During the last two years, I watched her struggle with a torn rotator cuff and a pinched nerve in her left shoulder that caused her months of anguish, while at the same time she was getting bouts of truly intolerable pain from her trigeminal neuralgia. The two conditions did a dance of torment around each other, and I hope it doesn’t sound self-indulgent to say that the only thing worse than experiencing that yourself is watching it happen to somebody you love.

We both could have given up so many times. Instead, we let our marriage sanctify us. Apparently we did something pretty special, because I have received message after message from people who have been telling me how inspired they were by the two of us, and how much my testimony about our marriage has meant to them. We seem to have spoken in very broad terms to the world about the true, genuine sanctity of marriage. I’m proud of that. That’s why it distresses me so much to see this sacred turf being used for political football of the most cynical kind.

As I said earlier, my experiences are personal, and Barbara’s and my marriage was unique. I do know two things, though. Nobody who has experienced the sanctity of marriage as I have would ever dream of leaving their beloved when he or she becomes sick. Nobody who has experienced the sanctity of marriage as I have would ever dream of denying it to anybody else.

Thursday, January 19, 2012

The Abyss

Since I began my very public sharing of grief over the loss of Barbara, I have been mildly astonished at the number of people who have expressed admiration for what they have been kind enough to call my courage, or even heroism. There has been almost a sense of awe surrounding some of the comments that have come my way, often from people I have known my entire life. I might as well reveal the fact that my composure and poise have a source that can be explained in some detail. This is a subject that I have contemplated writing about here for quite some time, and if there will ever be an appropriate moment, this is certainly it.

The immediate prompt came from an article in The Christian Century that was shared with me by a friend. If the magazine’s copyright policy had allowed me to post a link on Facebook, I wouldn’t need to write this, since Frederick Niedner has written the best commentary I have ever read on clinical depression and its spiritual significance. The core of his argument is found in the following statements:

“Anecdotal evidence suggests that creative types—artists, poets and musicians—and those particularly sensitive to others' emotional lives are especially susceptible, although a kind of chicken-and-egg riddle may underlie this perception. In The Denial of Death, Ernest Becker observes that the sanest individuals among us, the people most fully in touch with the reality of our mortal nature and flimsy constructs of meaning and purpose, are those whom fear and depression have reduced to states of catatonic paralysis. The rest of us who go blithely about our routines, oblivious to the fleeting quality of our arc through space and time, inhabit a fictional world, the insane realm of denial.”

Whether I am sane or not I will allow others to judge, but this cut to the quick for me. For years I was nearly maddened by this insidious disease, the open discussion of which remains one of our society’s last taboos. I am going to write here with brutal honesty in order to try to help make that taboo obsolete.

Yes, I suffered from clinical depression for more than twelve years, from my junior year in college until the age of 32. I may have had it even longer, but I became aware of it after a humiliating rejection by a girl I had fallen head over heels in love with. A kind of darkness descended over my life that is impossible to describe, since it is at once invisible and all-pervasive. I took one of the classic strategies for dealing with it—exactly the one that you would expect of a former National Merit Finalist with test scores in the stratosphere. I immersed myself in work and overachievement, earning a substantial fellowship to graduate school at Yale. Even in this Ivy League hideaway I distinguished myself, drawing attention from several faculty members who recognized in me the veritable prototype of a successful academic, complete with the Black Dog on a leash that always threatened to break out and demolish my feeble attempts at self-assertion.

In short, Yale claimed me as one of its own, having seen the pattern countless times before. I continued to throw myself into my work, renouncing romance and maintaining only a vestigial social life of any kind. And the depression grew worse, even though to all eyes I was thriving.

The crisis came during my penultimate dissertation year, when the Black Dog took up permanent residence on my upturned face and began the act of slow, sure suffocation that it knows so well. One of the pots in the kitchen of the apartment that I shared with another graduate student had been left out on the kitchen counter until it began to grow mold. I washed it carefully, but from that time forward became convinced that the mold remained and was slowly poisoning me and anybody else who had the misfortune of being a guest at our apartment. (We actually had a few.)

It was hard to imagine a mechanism, though, by which the scourge of our mold could get beyond the handful of our dinner guests, so a more subtle mechanism of transfer was needed. Within months, I had found it: the sound of my voice. It was not, after all, the chemical poisons from the mold that were fouling our guests; it was the mere act of listening to me. My voice, I imagined with pathetic grandiosity, had the real presence of a demonic power that could damn anybody who heard me to permanent separation from all hope. I was the shortcut to the Inferno. Worse, those so infected could infect others as well, giving them the power to spread the contagion. Soon, the mere act of having spoken socially to anybody else would make me effectively responsible for the eternal damnation of the entire world.

I knew, of course, that this was nonsense—and yet I didn’t, and so I spent increasingly long stretches of every day trying to argue myself rationally out of what had become a deep-seated obsession. As anybody who has tried it knows, you cannot argue your way out of an obsession, and the mere attempt to do so simply immerses you further, making the stakes even more desperate. It was after months of this ceaseless futility that I realized, quite simply, that I was going to have to kill myself. I didn’t want to do it, but I knew I had no choice. Life with that torment was simply unsustainable.

Volumes have been written about the overuse of anti-depressants in our culture, but I was most fortunate that at this moment my therapist realized that I was a candidate for them. This was before Prozac; I took monoamine oxidase inhibitors, which came with a host of dietary restrictions and possibly ghastly side effects. Within weeks of starting to take them, I experienced a miracle; the entire thought-complex that had imprisoned me in tighter and tighter chains for years simply lifted. Nothing in my own power could have made that happen, but a few little red pills a day had apparently done the trick.

In my newfound optimism I married, embarked on my professional career, and began to explore the previously shelved question of who I really was. Unfortunately, things didn’t go as smoothly as I could have hoped, and within a few years I had only a very part-time, temporary teaching job. It was at this point that my wife left me, performing the profoundly humiliating dumping maneuver yet again. Alone, with practically no income and even fewer prospects, I was forced to confront some long-delayed questions.

When I say forced, I mean it. Some of my passion on the subject of health insurance actually dates back to this time. With no insurance and only a minimal income, I could no longer afford the medications, so I was forced to wean myself off of them with no medical supervision whatsoever. Every time I lowered the dose, wave after wave of suppressed anger, fear and desperate sorrow surged to the surface and clawed at my consciousness. I realized that I had no choice but to finally own these emotions, albeit in small increments so that they no longer held the power of life and death over me. For the rest of that year, I doubled, then quadrupled, then exponentially expanded my emotional universe, all the while struggling through the everyday tasks that confront any newly single person trying to build a life.

Many days were so hard I really thought I would die of exhaustion or frustration—the difference wasn’t always entirely clear. Every time I picked myself up and repeated my new mantra: “If I can make it through this, I can make it through anything.” And so I did, and so I have.

It was at some point during all of this that I realized I no longer needed to ask myself whether I believed in God. I had been raised as an agnostic, for whom the existence of the deity was an open question, and the only unpardonable sin was to buy into a set of pre-made explanations. I had nevertheless flirted with Christianity in college, only to realize that our God is the God we know. Mine was a bully with a smirk, a sarcastic taunt and a maximum ability to inflict unbearable physical and emotional pain. Much of the anger that emerged during my “weaning” was directed at that God, and I told Him off repeatedly and with relish. I survived.

Contact with the genuinely divine, I found, sneaks in around you in rivulets of warmth and protection that are, to quote the title of Niedner’s article, “Barely Enough.” Nevertheless, enough they were, and by the time I met and married Barbara I had come to understand that everything I had done to recover from my depression was an expression of faith. Faith, of course, needs to have an object, and that object wasn’t me. This has remained the one ineluctable fact of existence for me ever since, and it renders theological debates more or less futile. This is what I know, and I can no other. Amazing grace how sweet the sound is the warp and fabric of my life, and I can no longer imagine it otherwise.

So on those occasions when I still have to step out into the abyss, not knowing if there is a foothold, I don’t worry so much any more. For those of you who are still with me, that is all there is to my heroism. I suppose, after all, that it is an appropriate subject of awe.

Saturday, January 7, 2012

An open letter to Rick Santorum

Dear Mr. Santorum -

You have presented yourself, in your run for the presidency, as a candidate of religious and moral values. I recently saw you quoted as saying that "the left has a religion, too. It’s just not based on the Bible. It’s based on the religion of self." [David Brooks, New York Times column, January 3]

I try to pay you the compliment of believing that you are well intentioned. Just yesterday, though, you were further quoted as telling the mother of a son who had survived cancer that people with pre-existing conditions should pay more for health care coverage because they make poor health care choices. [Igor Volsky, http://thinkprogress.org/health/2012/01/06/399357/santorum-to-mother-of-cancer-survivor-sick-are-to-blame-for-their-pre-existing-conditions-insurers-should-charge-them-more/?mobile=nc]

I can speak to your comments from a position of unique and painful authority. My wife recently died after decades of steadily worsening health due to radiation treatment she received for a brain tumor at 23. Without my group health insurance, she would have been unable to obtain any coverage at all.

Your position reminds me of comments made by some of the people at her parents' church, who told them that she must have done something terribly wrong for God to punish her in that way.

I'm sure you would qualify your statement, as you did to the mother of the son who had survived cancer, by assuring me that my wife did nothing wrong. Nevertheless, you are supporting a system that allows her and other innocent survivors of debilitating diseases to be treated as statistics and judged by whether they serve a corporate bottom line.

I urge you to consider the possibility that you are endorsing a position that has nothing to do with Biblical values, and everything to do with a societal ethos that makes everybody into a statistic and has rendered corporate profits more important than healing lives and saving souls. Perhaps our opponents' faults are always more visible than our own. From where I stand, though, you appear to be pursuing a religion of self with a single-minded intensity that is deeply offensive to many people who have been touched by serious illness.

Please back off and do some real soul-searching. You are causing genuine pain to people who have suffered much pain already. In doing so, you are undermining your claim to speak with moral authority, and are giving voice to the cruelest and ugliest forces in our public life: forces that are a profound threat to both religion and morality.

Sincerely,
Robin Wallace