Sunday, March 20, 2011

Hagar and Hafiz at Wheaton

I spent portions of the last three days at Wheaton College - sometimes called the "evangelical Harvard" - at the annual convention of the Forum on Music and Christian Scholarship. It's fair to say that this was one of the most meaningful academic meetings I have ever attended.

Our group is small, with fewer than a hundred members, which means we can have relatively intimate discussions and gatherings. Not all of us agree theologically, but we share the conviction that the mainstream academic world has marginalized talk either about God or about the myriad spiritual questions that for centuries have been essential to the definition of art in any of its forms. Over the past ten years, we have met at small, conservative colleges like Wheaton, but also at Ivy League schools and other large universities. Our membership is correspondingly diverse.

Since I had never visited Wheaton before, I wasn't sure what to expect. I am aware that the college holds some theological positions with which I, as a liberal Christian, am deeply uncomfortable. (Catholics are not welcome on the faculty, for example, and belief in Biblical "inerrancy" is widely held.) However, the professors and students that I spoke to were impressively open-minded. In particular, I will single out a speech by Harold Best, the retired dean of the Conservatory of Music, who succinctly articulated many of the things that I wish had been said to me when I was in graduate school: art begins from the commonality of being human at the simplest level; the most sophisticated statements of musicians belong to that commonality because they articulate it profoundly; discourse about art and education needs to retreat from superlatives (excellence, awesome) that have been rendered meaningless through overuse and recover an understanding of what it means to be "good," both as humans and as artists; interdisciplinary study is a dangerous misnomer, because the whole human heritage suffers when disciplinary lines become rigid enough to require it.

I also attended a performance of the Brahms Requiem at Orchestra Hall in Chicago on Friday evening that featured the Wheaton undergraduate orchestra along with all of the college's choral ensembles and the Apollo Chorus of Chicago. It was stunning. During intermission (there were some shorter pieces performed first), I realized that the man sitting next to me in Row H was in fact the president of Wheaton College. We talked for a while about the role of a college president in helping the faculty to educate students and the need for the faculty to place that goal above our individual careers or reputations. If he wasn't just talking a good talk, and if every college president in the country had similar priorities, we'd all be better off for it.

The most meaningful part of the entire meeting for me, though, was a worship service on Friday morning. In the main auditorium of the Billy Graham center, FMCS member Cheryl Pauls, who teaches at Canadian Mennonite University, gave a multi-media presentation about Hagar, the Egyptian slave/concubine of Abraham who is often considered the first ancestor of Islam. You would have had to be there to understand how moving this was. Cheryl managed to retell Hagar's story from the scraps that appear in Genesis in a way that invested her with dignity and her son Ishmael with divine favor, albeit of a kind that in the West is little understood. Apart from Genesis, the central text was a poem by the Persian writer Hafiz, whose text I linked yesterday on my Facebook wall. "I have come into this world to see this," Hafiz wrote: "the sword drop from men's hands even at the height of their arc of rage, because we have finally realized there is just one flesh we can wound." The audience watched in stunned silence at the suggestion of a peaceful reconciliation with the Muslim world, presented from the Muslim perspective within a Christian worship service. We sang along with enthusiasm when asked to do so, and then applauded with wild gratitude at the end. I nearly wept.

http://www.panhala.net/Archive/I_Have_Come_Into_This_World.html

Now, it turns out there are some wrinkles. Wheaton had specifically told Cheryl that this presentation could not be given during one of the student chapel services, which means that only a few Wheaton students got to hear it (most of them were helping with the music). It also turns out that the translations of Hafiz by Daniel Ladinsky, around which the service was based, are controversial. Some have claimed that he didn't so much translate Hafiz as write new poems under his name. Interestingly, though, this would be nothing new. Goethe wrote his "West- oestlicher Divan," which inspired many Romantic song composers, out of a similar desire to bridge the East-West, Christian/Muslim divide by imitating Hafiz.

What truly intrigued me was the reviews I read on Amazon while waiting for my flight back to Texas. Most reviewers were overwhelmed by the beauty and spiritual depth of Hafiz/Ladinsky's verse. The greatest dissenter was an English speaker who claimed to know Farsi fluently and to have read all of Hafiz in the original; he said outright that he couldn't recognize any of Hafiz in Ladinsky's versions. Another review was by a native Iranian who grew up hearing Hafiz, and thought Ladinsky's versions were the very best translations he had ever read. Clearly, Hafiz is still bringing dramatic differences between Western and Eastern perspectives into the open.


So in conclusion: good meeting, positive impressions of Wheaton, but also regret that my friend Cheryl was not allowed to bring her moving plea for reconciliation to the college's students, who needed to hear it as much as anybody. We've got work to do.

Friday, March 11, 2011

This is how you do a tax protest

Like many Americans, I've been doing my taxes. Let me start by laying a few things on the line.

• I fully accept that paying taxes is one of the responsibilities of those who live in a civilized society.

• I am perfectly willing to pay taxes in order to help the government do all the things it does.

• Knowing that the US has some of the lowest tax rates of any advanced country in the world, I have always found claims that our taxes are too high to be ludicrous.

• I nevertheless claim all the exemptions I am entitled to. This year, that means I am itemizing what will likely end up totaling more than $14,000 worth of out-of-pocket medical expenses for my family. That's what we had to pay last year even though we have health insurance. The part of that which exceeds 7.5% of my income is tax deductible.

• When this is all finished, I will still have paid thousands of dollars last year to the federal government, to the state of Texas in the form of sales taxes, and to McLennan county in the form of property taxes. I am a major taxpayer, and I'm entitled to expect something in return.

In fact, I am considerably more entitled to help determine how my money is spent than are ExxonMobil, General Electric, Bank of America and Citigroup, all of which paid $0 in federal taxes last year. http://www.usuncut.org/about

I am also entitled to get quite indignant at a chart like the following, which shows how many things I care deeply about—as should anyone with a conscience—are being slashed to allow wealthy corporations and billionaires even greater tax breaks than they were already receiving.
http://jackdean.posterous.com/must-see-chart-this-is-what-class-war-looks-l

And, when I find that the state of Michigan is planning to raise taxes on poor people and the elderly and give the proceeds directly to billionaires, without using any of it to address the budget deficit that people keep complaining about,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AUpO1QFMDtM, I am entitled to say that our country has lost its moral balance completely.

THIS IS OBSCENE.

Fortunately, UKUncut, which I wrote about here recently, has come to the US. If you think what I'm describing here is deeply immoral—if it offends you at the gut level that the rich are pulling all the levers of government power in order to take money away from the poor, and are even willing to depose elected officials in order to do it (see the video if you don't believe me), please join me in clicking on the first of my links and affirming your support for the real tea party: the one that is not a bought and paid subsidiary of Fox News, and hence actually deserves our support.


Wednesday, March 9, 2011

Metanoiete

Today, like many Christians, I will attend a church service at which somebody will smudge some ashes on my forehead while saying: "Remember that you are dust, and to dust you will return." This memento mori is the traditional beginning of Lent.

Not everybody does Lent, of course. For those who do, though, there's a sense that this is a pretty serious time, marked by lots of soul-searching and giving up of something that we enjoy. The payoff, I suppose, is that when Easter comes, you can stop doing all that. Until next year.

I want to say something very personal here. I like Lent. I don't find it oppressive at all. Maybe that's because I understand that the word "metanoiete," translated in most versions of the New Testament as "repent," actually means "renew your mind." It's not about giving up things. It's about expanding yourself and embracing what you might have rejected and condemned.

I first had the ashes imposed in my early 30s. I wasn't brought up religious, so religious ritual had a kind of novel appeal for me that it still retains. I'm not sure what I expected to happen afterward, though. To my great surprise, what I experienced was freedom. Freedom from fear, freedom from dogma, freedom from relentless self-criticism. Lent, I discovered, is a time to let your spirituality free - to let the permeable membranes that separate you from the rest of reality breathe and stretch.

Ever since then, I have experienced Lent every year as a joyful new beginning. I have experienced repentance as something that is not limited to Lent, but that, thankfully, goes on constantly. Oh, it will be very somber tonight, and that will fill a desperately needed hole in a world in which religion is increasingly limited to the upbeat and affirming. Neither religion nor life works that way, and this yearly reminder of that fact makes us whole. How glad I am to have discovered that.

Saturday, March 5, 2011

Beethoven for spring break

You've all been patiently reading my thoughts on various political issues. Just to show that this is a multi-purpose blog, I've created my first YouTube video and have embedded it here. This is a Beethoven sonata that I'm particularly fond of, and I hope to perform it in a few months on a joint recital with my son Jeremy, who will also play the piano and sing. We'll be raising money to help fund his trip to the UK this summer as a People to People Student Ambassador.

In the meantime, though, I just like this music, and I thought some of you might enjoy it as well. If you're curious, the passage from about 3:14 to 3:28 is the one I described recently on Facebook as "one of the strangest passages of tonal music ever written."

Enjoy, and happy spring break!

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Hooray for free speech

So far, this has been free speech week. In an 8-1 decision, the US Supreme Court upheld the right of people like the Westboro Baptist Church to picket funerals. They're the ones who believe they have a mission from God to make the rest of the people in the US hate them so we'll all go to hell and God's righteousness will be upheld. (I'm not making that up.) Both liberals and conservatives on the court (with the strange exception of Justice Alito) agreed that this is the price we have to pay for living in a free society.

Then there was the story I shared this morning on Facebook. In case you missed it, Fox News tried to open up a franchise in Canada. It turns out, though, that they had a significant hurdle to clear that doesn't exist in the US. In order to bring his friends at Fox across the border, Stephen Harper, Canada's right-wing prime minister, had to ask the Canadian Radio-Television and Communications Commission to reconsider an inconvenient restriction that they have so far managed to impose on Canada's broadcasters. Apparently, in Canada, news organizations are not allowed to lie on the air. That's why Fox won't be moving north.

There is something so blatantly shameless about a head of state appealing for the right of broadcasters to lie to the public that there's really little more to say. But I'll say it anyway. To quote Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., "Harper's attempts to make lying legal on Canadian television are a stark admission that right-wing political ideology can only dominate national debate through dishonest propaganda."

Got that? Fox lies. Everybody knows that Fox lies. "Since corporate profit-taking is not an attractive vessel for populism, a political party or broadcast network that makes itself the tool of corporate and financial elites must lie to make its agenda popular with the public." THE. PRIME. MINISTER. OF. CANADA. HAD. TO. ASK. HIS. OWN. REGULATORS. TO. ALLOW. FOX. TO. LIE. Otherwise he knew perfectly well that he had no hope of setting up a similar propaganda service north of the border.

Where is Justice Alito when we need him?

Monday, February 28, 2011

This one is for my friends in Texas

Two articles I've read recently are begging to be connected, and the purpose of this post is to make the connection and get people thinking.

The first one actually came second. In a scathing column this morning, Paul Krugman made it plain that our governor, Rick Perry, having "discovered" a massive budget deficit that he didn't notice while campaigning for re-election, plans to take out virtually all of the damage on our children by crippling education in Texas. This is not an overstatement.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/28/opinion/28krugman.html?_r=1&ref=opinion

The second one, which I discovered a few days ago, shows how people in Britain realized that they didn't have to take the drastic, punitive cuts being proposed by their new government lying down. They discovered that a single company, Vodafone, owed almost enough in unpaid taxes to solve the crisis.
There was no need for new taxes, it turned out; all that was needed was the will of British citizens to insist that Vodafone and other corporate delinquents pay what they owed so that the entire British social support system did not have to be destroyed.

http://www.thenation.com/article/158282/how-build-progressive-tea-party

Naturally, this has me wondering what companies haven't paid their taxes in Texas. Apparently, all it takes is for enough people to make it clear that they won't stand for it. If, like me, you want a decent future for our children, please send suggestions for how we can duplicate the striking success of UKuncut. Who are the corporate tax evaders that stand between us and our children's future? It's quite clear that unless we identify them and hold their feet to the fire, Perry is going to proceed with his plans to destroy education in Texas. It's also clear that we don't have to let it happen.

Ideas? Suggestions?

Saturday, February 26, 2011

Don't know much about...

I've been stuck at home sick for most of the week, and I've had time to read and think (things I would never ordinarily do). There are plenty of interesting observations just in the Opinion section of today's New York Times.

• From Gail Collins: Mike Huckabee, whom I used to like, has published a book in which he compares the Obama administration to "the kid in school who waves his A test score in front of the entire class but never gets picked to play baseball. He’s an arrogant nerd, and no matter how smart he is, he can’t hit, he can’t throw and he can’t run." Thanks, Mike. I didn't see myself as arrogant, nor did I wave any of my grades in front of the class, but I never got picked to play anything, and the ritual of watching every single classmate chosen before me for every single game we ever played was humiliating in a way I'd never expect you to understand. Thanks for trying.

• From Bob Herbert: "Among the many heartening things about the workers fighting back in Wisconsin, Ohio and elsewhere is the spotlight that is being thrown on the contemptuous attitude of the corporate elite and their handmaidens in government toward ordinary working Americans: police officers and firefighters, teachers, truck drivers, janitors, health care aides, and so on. These are the people who do the daily grunt work of America. How dare we treat them with contempt." So it's not just us nerds who get treated that way. Good to know.

• From Charles Blow: "It is savagely immoral and profoundly inconsistent to insist that women endure unwanted — and in some cases dangerous — pregnancies for the sake of 'unborn children,' then eliminate financing designed to prevent those children from being delivered prematurely, rendering them the most fragile and vulnerable of newborns. How is this humane?" I don't know, Charles. It seems pretty consistent with the last two observations.

Nerds.
Police officers.
Firefighters.
Teachers.
Truck drivers.
Janitors.
Health care aides.
Mothers with sick children.

Put us together and we make up a pretty large swath of the population. What do we all have in common? It's interesting that nerds are the only ones that Huckabee (whom I used to admire) considers fair game for public ridicule. Imagine if he had said that the Obama administration is like "the kid in school who waves his firefighting abilities in front of the entire class but never gets picked to do anything else because no matter how good he is at rescuing people from burning buildings, when you get right down to it his job is expendable." Doesn't have quite the same ring to it. That's why you need to read between the lines.